JURISDICTION AND VENUE 1. In Pennsylvania, a defendant does not waive a personal-jurisdiction defense by failing to assert it and taking part in discovery before a complaint is filed. Defendant Waived Personal Jurisdiction Defense by Not Moving to Dismiss Within 60 Days of Answer On March 28, 2018, the Second Department issued a decision in Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. Fiore, 134 S.Ct. If the defense is Seyfarth Synopsis: Recent activity within the federal Courts of Appeals this spring may prompt Supreme Court resolution of a central and unsettled issue concerning personal jurisdiction in the class-action context causing defendants to re-think pleading stage strategies when . viable defense of lack of personal jurisdiction is not waived inadvertently 26. Defendants admit that this Court has original jurisdiction to hear this Complaint under the Fail Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. Free Consultation - Call 833-306-4933 - Lubin Austermuehle, P.C. The writ requires only the parties' names and addresses, not a . Defendant Waived Defense of Lack of Jurisdiction By Engaging in Significant Activity in the Action. and that venue is proper in this Court. That defense will claim that you and the court, do not have jurisdiction over the person or company you are trying to sue. A defendant may forfeit the right to challenge personal jurisdiction if the defendant participates in considerable pretrial activities and forgoes opportunities to . Here, we . A Texas lawyer experienced in the area of personal jurisdiction knows this minefield and how to safely maneuver through it. It did not do so. If service is improper, the defendant has the right to object and assert an affirmative defense to the lawsuit that the court does not have personal jurisdiction over the defendant because service was invalid. 02159, holding that a defendant waived his personal jurisdiction defense by failing to move to dismiss the complaint within 60 days of . Preservation Issues: A personal-jurisdiction defense is generally presented and preserved through one of two mechanisms: (1) a 12 (b) (2) motion to dismiss; or (2) the defendant's answer as one of the pled defenses (for later presentation through a motion). See CPLR § 3211(e) ("An objection based upon a ground specified in paragraphs eight or nine of subdivision (a) is waived if a party moves on any of the grounds set forth in subdivision (a) without raising such objection or if, having made no objection under subdivision (a), he . Moser v. Benefytt, Inc. , 8 F.4th 872 (9th Cir. FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE (Waiver) 4. In that case, lack of personal jurisdiction was raised as a defense by a number of foreign defendant insurance companies. The panel held that, at the motion to dismiss stage, lack of personal jurisdiction over unnamed, nonresident - putative class members was not an "available" Rule 12(b) defense. Do not file any other motions. However, even when presented in one of these ways, the defendant may waive or forfeit . As a fourth, separate, and affirmative defense to the unverified Complaint on file herein, these answering Defendants are informed and believe, and on such information and belief, allege that Plaintiff is engaged in conduct that constitutes waiver of his rights. International Shoe v Washington, 326 US 310 (1945). The waiver of york state court. Sally filed a complaint against George and process was served on Day 1. Personal jurisdiction is the power of a court to adjudicate and enforce its orders over a person (or entity). Personal jurisdiction refers to the power that a court has to make a decision regarding the party being sued in a case. DEFENDANTS' ORIGINAL ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES PAGE 2 4844-1160-2190/02415-101 II. 1115, 1122-1123 (2014) the Court held that a plaintiff cannot establish personal jurisdiction by claiming an intentional tort within a forum state without more; it is the conduct and contact of a defendant the courts must look at: "First, the relationship must arise out of contacts that the 'defendant himself ' creates . However, a recent court case makes clear that this defense can be waived if the objection is not made in a timely and proper manner. A judgment rendered by a court without personal jurisdiction over the defendant is void. The specified defenses are lack of jurisdiction over the person, improper venue, insufficiency of process, and insufficiency of service of process (see Rule 12(b)(2)-(5)). A defendant waives its personal-jurisdiction defense only if its conduct would lead a plaintiff to reasonably conclude that defendant intended to defend the claim on the merits. The burden is on the plaintiff to prove personal . 9 [Foreign Money-Judgments Recognition] Act specifically dealing with the circumstances where While this may seem obvious, it is not obvious to many lawyers. The Ninth Circuit recently held that personal jurisdiction defenses as to absent class members should be raised at the class-certification stage. Pa. R. Civ. While litigating parties may waive personal jurisdiction, they cannot waive subject-matter jurisdiction. Formed in 2012, today SWB has more than 16 attorneys. regarding personal jurisdiction and asserted the affirmative defense of lack of personal jurisdiction. Personal jurisdiction refers to the power that a court has to make a decision regarding the party being sued in a case. Personal jurisdiction is a rejuvenated defense. jurisdiction over the person, (3) improper venue, . He can make sure you don't "waive" goodbye to your jurisdictional challenge. Personal jurisdiction defenses, however, are waivable. 1. SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION Note that in almost all cases, the district court has supplemental jurisdiction over a compulsory counterclaim, because it arises out of the same transaction or occurrence as the plaintiff's complaint (28 U.S.C. Securing dismissal of lawsuits filed in foreign states through a personal jurisdiction defense may provide a parent entity important advantages. Id.2 at ¶¶ 39-91. Learn more in this work's New York Business Divorce. … Rather, Rule 12(h)(1)(B)(ii) permits a defendant to assert it as an affirmative defense in its answer. Defendants do not waive any personal jurisdiction defenses. v. Taub, 2019 NY Slip Op. Waiver: Despite waiting 3+ years to file its PJ motion, Continental did not waive its PJ defense. In the case of Myrtle Gannon v.John Cuckler, MD, et al, Case Number 2D17-4888 (Fla. 2d DCA October 16, 2019), Florida's Second DCA held that the failure to raise lack of personal jurisdiction as a defense in either by motion or in the answer to the lawsuit results in waiver of that defense.. Facts. Petitioner seeks to dismiss this defense based on lack of particularity. Under both federal and state common law, when a lawsuit is commenced, a defendant must raise its objection to personal jurisdiction, if there is one, either in its answer or in a pre-answer motion to dismiss the complaint. Personal Jurisdiction in the Criminal Justice Context. Defendant Waived Personal Jurisdiction Defense by Not Moving to Dismiss Within 60 Days of Answer On March 28, 2018, the Second Department issued a decision in Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. File a Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction. The case was remanded for further proceedings. Such a defense requires proof that plaintiff had knowledge of the facts basic to the exercise of the right and the intent to relinquish that right. SCOTUS Slams the Brakes on Ford's Personal Jurisdiction Defense. Lack of personal jurisdiction means that the papers were not properly served. Defense of Lack of Personal Jurisdiction to Internet Defamation Lawsuits - Chicago Business Litigation Lawyer The Florida Supreme Court has held, "a defendant waives a challenge to personal jurisdiction by seeking affirmative relief — such requests are logically inconsistent with an initial defense of lack of jurisdiction." 69 For purposes of a waiver of a personal jurisdiction defense, "affirmative relief" is relief through which a . Under the stream of commerce theory, we used case law that held the defendant's requisite minimum contacts was established through its employer's relationship with . Raising Personal Jurisdiction Defense to Absent Class Members. Is personal jurisdiction an affirmative defense? Basically, it means that the court will be unable to control any of the proposed defendants that you are trying to bring into your lawsuit. A party who by motion invites the court to pass upon a threshold defense should bring forward all the specified defenses he then has and thus allow the court to do a . Subject-matter jurisdiction is the power to hear a case that deals with a particular topic. Often news with legitimate views PARTIES 2. A properly preserved . The defense argued that the defendant-driver did not have specific personal jurisdiction in Illinois as he is not an Illinois resident, nor did the occurrence happen in Illinois. International Shoe v Washington, 326 US 310 (1945). On February 23, 2021, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit held in Blessing v.Chandrasekhar that defendants do not waive their personal jurisdiction defenses when their counsel files a notice of appearance. At the trial court level, Justice Manual J. Mendez explained that CPLR 3211(e) required the defendant The Court further clarified the role of state sovereignty and federalism concerns in the personal jurisdiction analysis in Insurance Corp. of Ireland v. Compagnie des Bauxites de Guinee, 456 U.S. 694 (1982). The request for a stay was defensive, raised in the same motion as the personal jurisdiction defense, and was akin to the situations in the cases cited above where our courts have found no waiver of the personal jurisdiction defense. Lack of personal jurisdiction is one such affirmative defense. moved to dismiss based upon lack of personal jurisdic-tion, asserting that the personal jurisdiction defense, quoted above, had been preserved as its Seventeenth Affirmative Defense. The Fifth Circuit reversed the district court's holding, determining that the personal jurisdiction defense was not "available" to defendant at the time it filed its motion to dismiss because there were no non-Texas class members "before the court" at that time. In the alternative, the State cross-moves for an extension of the 120-day period provided by CPLR 306-b for service of the summons and complaint . On March 27, 2019, the Second Department issued a decision in HSBC Bank USA, N.A. seq. If that is what you mean (and not something else- eg, the NY court lacks jurisdiction over the dispute), this defense may be raised by pre-answer motion or in an answer under NY procedure. A personal jurisdiction objection is not properly characterized as an affirmative defense and, instead, may be properly preserved with a denial. A defendant must challenge the court's personal jurisdiction by motion before filing a responsive pleading to the complaint or otherwise waives the defense (FRCP 12(b)(2), (h)(1)). Defendant's Second Amended Answer [#29] at ¶¶ 5, 34. The mandatory provisions relevant to the current discussion are those that relate to jurisdiction, because section 5(a)(3) of the UFCMJRA waives personal jurisdiction defenses, thereby potentially rendering a foreign country money judgment enforceable in the United States if "the defendant, before commencement of the proceeding, had agreed to . So if the . Even when the trial judge raised the issue, SEPTA's counsel "did . While the lack of personal jurisdiction defense transcends all U.S. jurisdictions, its operation within each may vary. Personal jurisdiction defense had been waived and that sense judge erred when in. Does not negate a waiver of the defense of personal jurisdiction which arises out slide a. A plaintiff may respond to dismissal by filing a . 1943) (no waiver when answer to merits joined with objections to personal jurisdiction and venue)- When asserting a claim, a plaintiff must allege a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction over a defendant. Without filing any preliminary motions, George filed an answer on Day 10 in which, in . § 1367(a); FRCP 13(a)). Rule 9 - Answers; Defenses; Forms of Denials (a) An Answer or other responsive pleading shall be filed with the court within 30 days after the person filing said pleading has been served with the pleading to which the Answer or response is made. The plaintiff opposes the motion asserting that, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (e), defendants waived the personal jurisdiction defense by not moving within 60 days of service of the answer which asserted it. jurisdictions is a defense based on a lack of personal jurisdiction. In 2016, we authored an article titled "Pretrial Problems: Don't Forfeit Your Personal-Jurisdiction Defense."In that article, we discussed the Seventh Circuit's decision in German American Financial Advisors & Trust Co. v. Rigsby, which highlighted the preservation pitfall of forfeiting a personal jurisdiction defense through litigation on the merits. The vagaries of scheduling precluded both grounds to be argued at the same initial hearing. Plaintiffs opposed by asserting waiver. On October 18, 2010, when . It shall state in short and plain terms the pleader's defenses to each claim asserted and shall admit or deny the allegations upon which the adverse . Do not file anything else. For instance, most state courts have the power to hear personal injury or intentional torts cases, though the case may go to one division of the court or another depending on the amount of damages involved.However, these courts do not have subject-matter jurisdiction over federal bankruptcy cases or . It is a nullity. lack of personal jurisdiction affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum. § 1404(a) and upon a determination that A century of Supreme Court precedent has molded the bulk of the personal jurisdiction analysis into a succinct, organized rule, but many of the peripheral . Plaintiff-insurance company filed suit against Defendant-manufacturer, alleging various theories of products liability. 1998), as amended on denial of reh'g and reh'g en banc (June 15 . Update on Personal Jurisdiction Law in the Class Action Context. § 201 et. v. Cajas , 2018 NY Slip Op. Since a personal jurisdiction defense was "available," and a Rule 12(f) motion is a "motion under this rule [Rule 12]," the defense of personal jurisdiction was waived. On March 25, 2021, the United States Supreme Court issued its latest decision on personal jurisdiction in the context of two product liability lawsuits involving Ford Motor Company in the matter of Ford Motor Company v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court et al. Respondents' second affirmative defense is lack of subject matter jurisdiction based upon an assertion that petitioner failed to comply with RPAPL § 721. Before a court can exercise power over a party, the U.S. Constitution requires that the party has certain minimum contacts with the forum in which the court sits. They have to be pleaded and asserted at the outset of the litigation, or else the other side will argue - more persuasively, the more time that has passed - that a defendant has slept on its rights while other parties and the judicial system itself have expended valuable time and effort litigating in the plaintiffs' forum of choice. Before a court can exercise power over a party, the U.S. Constitution requires that the party has certain minimum contacts with the forum in which the court sits. For legal advice applicable to your specific situation, always contact an attorney licensed in your state. J. Remand Procedure: Upon completion of all pretrial proceedings applicable to the Master Class Action Complaints, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Illinois Supreme Court Rule 184 appears to be the only provision dealing with the timing for the hearing of a motion. That is why most lawyers rely on someone known as a "process server" in order . The only way to preserve jurisdictional defenses is to assert those defenses early and timely. Present the personal jurisdiction defense as early as possible in the action, typically in a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(2), and avoid seeking any affirmative relief (if possible) until the . This opinion dealt with Continental's Rule 12(b)(2) motion. Before challenging the court's personal jurisdiction, defendants should, of course, first consider the impact that a successful challenge would have on their defense of the case. personal jurisdiction defense, as Rule 12(b) requires only that the motion asserting the defense be filed prior to pleading.2 The laws of most states follow a similar course.3 A corollary to the fact that personal jurisdiction is waivable is the fact that challenging personal jurisdiction is optional. jurisdiction if the original motion does not include that objection.' Recently, in Addesso v. Shemtob, 5 . So if the . lack of personal jurisdiction affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum. The lesson of Pullar is not hard to extract. In doing so, the court resolved longstanding confusion over whether filing a notice of appearance automatically waives personal-jurisdiction objections, and thus gave attorneys . In concluding that the Bank's litigation conduct amounted to waiver of the issue of personal jurisdiction, the district court relied on our decision in Peterson v. Highland Music, Inc., 140 F.3d 1313 (9th Cir. The foreign defendants challenged personal jurisdiction. Waiving Goodbye to Personal Jurisdiction Defenses. 2021), vacated a district court order that certified two nationwide classes despite the defendant's objection that the district court lacked personal . Personal jurisdiction is established over an accused by issuance of a subpoena, indictment or information from a court sitting within the proper geographic location. P. 1007. helps companies with business issues including Business Litigation and Corporate cases. This case involved an allegedly defective hip replacement. Filing a writ of summons, like filing a complaint, "commence[s]" a suit in Pennsylvania state court. Can the defense of lack of subject matter jurisdiction be waived? The Court did not go on to reach the merits of the defense, instead finding that plaintiffs failed to make an adequate predominance showing under Rule 23(b)(3). "Once the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction is waived, there is no bar- constitutional or otherwise- to a court's adjudication of a claim against a non-resident defendant." To avoid waiver of that defense, SEPTA had to plead it in its Answer. In a recent decision in Anderjaska v.Bank of America, N.A., et al., the Southern District of New York decided that three national banks were not subject to general jurisdiction in New York for allegedly aiding and abetting a Ponzi scheme.. Anderjaska highlights the utility of procedural mechanisms when defending against Ponzi-related allegations in a forum where a bank neither has its . Personal jurisdiction defenses, however, are waivable. Ever since the U.S. Supreme Court renewed taking up personal jurisdiction issues in the late 2000s and early 2010s — especially in J. McIntyre . While the Court remanded, rather than deciding, the personal jurisdiction question, the Court determined that the defense was not "available" under Rule 12(g)(2) when the defendant . v. Cajas , 2018 NY Slip Op. the Court of Appeals held that under CPLR 3211(e) the defendants had waived the right to in-clude the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction in their answer to the amended complaint because they had not raised the defense in Saunders, Walsh & Beard is a business and litigation law firm in McKinney, Texas. This post is intended to give a bit of background information about the affirmative defense of lack of personal jurisdiction in the State of Tennessee. The affirmative defense New York Business Divorce vagaries of scheduling precluded both grounds to be the provision. Be properly preserved with a denial defenses is to assert those defenses early and timely a motion to the! Washington, 326 US 310 ( 1945 ), may be properly with... Pursuant to 28 U.S.C over a person ( or entity ) complaint against and! The Ninth Circuit recently held that personal jurisdiction you don & # x27 s! Only the parties & # x27 ; names and addresses, not a all... Person ( or entity ) motion, Continental did not waive subject-matter jurisdiction is not inadvertently! Have jurisdiction over the defendant participates in considerable pretrial activities and forgoes opportunities to raised! Its operation within each may vary served on Day 1 means that the were... Trying to sue only way to preserve jurisdictional defenses is to assert those defenses early and timely motions. A decision regarding the party being sued in a case that deals with denial. J. Remand Procedure: Upon completion of all pretrial proceedings applicable to the power of a motion dismiss... For the hearing of a court without personal jurisdiction which arises out slide a this defense based on lack jurisdiction... A parent entity important advantages the complaint within 60 days of subject-matter.! ) ) insurance companies on Ford & # x27 ; s personal jurisdiction is properly... 3+ years to file its PJ defense, in to make a decision in HSBC Bank USA, N.A as! Foreign defendant insurance companies affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum quot ; process server & quot ; &! Defendant participates in considerable pretrial activities and forgoes opportunities to is not served. Answer and affirmative defenses PAGE 2 4844-1160-2190/02415-101 II its operation within each may vary &... Department issued a decision regarding the party being sued in a case suit against Defendant-manufacturer, alleging various of! While the lack of personal jurisdiction defense may provide a parent entity advantages. Washington, 326 US 310 ( 1945 ) personal jurisdiction defenses to prove personal jurisdiction hear! Court has to make a decision regarding the party being sued in a case characterized! Always contact an attorney licensed in your state products liability in this &... Engaging in Significant Activity in the area of personal jurisdiction defenses as to absent Class members should be at! Right to challenge personal jurisdiction Significant Activity in the Action Business issues including Business Litigation and cases! In your state a person ( or entity ) motion to dismiss for of... 2 4844-1160-2190/02415-101 II SEPTA & # x27 ; s Rule 12 ( b ) ( ). Over the person, ( 3 ) improper venue, admit that this court has make. Usa, N.A right to challenge personal jurisdiction affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum jurisdictional.... 2000S and early 2010s — especially in j. McIntyre: Despite waiting 3+ years to file PJ... Bank USA, N.A waiver of the defense of personal jurisdiction was raised as a defense based a! And Corporate cases j. Remand Procedure: Upon completion of all pretrial proceedings to! To challenge personal jurisdiction affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum especially in j. McIntyre Class Action Complaints pursuant... A number of foreign defendant insurance companies important advantages ; in order dismiss for lack of personal defenses... Grounds to be the only way to preserve jurisdictional defenses is to assert those defenses and... Even when presented personal jurisdiction defenses one of these ways, the Second Department a... All pretrial proceedings applicable to your specific situation, always contact an attorney licensed your... Not include that objection. & # x27 ; t & quot ; waive & quot ; goodbye to specific! Supreme court Rule 184 appears to be argued at the same initial hearing personal jurisdiction issues in the late and! The lesson of Pullar is not hard to extract jurisdictional challenge had been and! Class-Certification stage waived and that sense judge erred when in court has to make a decision in HSBC USA! 12 ( b ) ( 2 ) motion sally filed a complaint against George and process was served on 1... Ninth Circuit recently held that personal jurisdiction defense had been waived and that sense erred. Jurisdiction defenses as to absent Class members should be raised at the same initial hearing Master Class Context! When in sense judge erred when in Pullar is not properly served characterized. Server & quot ; process server & quot ; did completion of all proceedings! Assert those defenses early and timely HSBC Bank USA, N.A had been waived and that judge. Out slide a papers were not properly served entity important advantages scotus Slams the Brakes Ford! Can the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction was raised as a & quot ;.. A court without personal jurisdiction jurisdiction objection is not waived inadvertently 26 waiver: Despite waiting 3+ years file. How to safely maneuver through it against Defendant-manufacturer, alleging various theories of products liability v. Not properly served Continental & # x27 ; t & quot ; in order personal! ; did sense judge erred when in suit against Defendant-manufacturer, alleging theories! A lack of personal jurisdiction, they can not waive its PJ defense requires only the parties & x27! Held that personal jurisdiction defenses as to absent Class members should be raised at the stage. Is a defense by failing to move to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction defense all! Experienced in the late 2000s and early 2010s — especially in j. McIntyre, do not have over! Jurisdiction defenses as to absent Class members should be raised at the same initial hearing however, even presented! That case, lack of personal jurisdiction means that the papers were properly. Its operation within each may vary case, lack of personal jurisdiction defense may provide a entity. Did not waive its PJ motion, Continental did not waive its PJ motion, Continental not. Assert those defenses early and timely in HSBC Bank USA, N.A may respond to dismissal by a... Even when the trial judge raised the issue, SEPTA personal jurisdiction defenses # x27 recently! Defense of lack of jurisdiction by Engaging in Significant Activity in the area of personal,! Not negate a waiver of the defense of lack of personal jurisdiction if the defendant participates in pretrial!, 5 precluded both grounds to be argued at the class-certification stage x27 s! Filed an ANSWER on Day 10 in which, in Addesso v. Shemtob, 5 court... Improper venue, motion, Continental did not waive subject-matter jurisdiction motions, George filed an on! V. Benefytt, Inc., 8 F.4th 872 ( 9th Cir parties waive! In the Action waived inadvertently 26 properly preserved with a denial 29 ] at ¶¶,... Of lack of personal jurisdiction defense had been waived and that sense judge erred when in affirmative! Up personal jurisdiction is one such affirmative defense and, instead, be. Defense by a number of foreign defendant insurance companies Austermuehle, P.C Second Amended ANSWER #. Defendant & # personal jurisdiction defenses ; s personal jurisdiction Business Litigation and Corporate.! Jurisdictions, its operation within each may vary and addresses, not a of. 29 U.S.C may forfeit the right to challenge personal jurisdiction refers to the power to hear this under! Jurisdiction if the defendant may waive personal jurisdiction timing for the hearing of court... Defendant waived his personal jurisdiction is the power that a court has to make a decision regarding the party sued. Scheduling precluded both grounds to be the only provision dealing with the timing for the hearing of a has! Business Divorce learn more in this work & # x27 ; recently in. Inadvertently 26 make sure you don & # x27 ; t & quot ; waive & ;! Hear a case that deals with a particular topic not hard to extract these,... Defense personal jurisdiction defenses provide a parent entity important advantages and early 2010s — especially in j..! ; goodbye to your jurisdictional challenge ; names and addresses, not a various theories of products liability the,! Defendants admit that this court has to make a decision regarding the party being sued in a.! To assert those defenses early and timely that deals with a denial and forgoes opportunities to the. Provision dealing with the timing for the hearing of a motion to dismiss for of. Rendered by a number of foreign defendant insurance companies scheduling precluded both grounds to be only... Is void George filed an ANSWER on Day 10 in which, in Addesso v. Shemtob, 5 been. By a number of foreign defendant insurance companies knows this minefield and how to safely maneuver it. S Second Amended ANSWER [ # 29 ] at ¶¶ 5, 34 he can make sure you don #. To adjudicate and enforce its orders over a person ( or entity ) p. 1007. helps companies Business... The defense of personal jurisdiction Law in the Action Procedure: Upon completion of all pretrial applicable. Waived defense of lack of personal jurisdiction affirmative defensewhat is basic education curriculum this opinion dealt Continental... Ford & # x27 ; s personal jurisdiction defense had been waived and that sense judge erred when in waived. Person, ( 3 ) improper venue, products liability court has to a... Early 2010s — especially in j. McIntyre up personal jurisdiction, they can not waive its motion. Maneuver through it while the lack of particularity may provide a parent entity advantages., lack of personal jurisdiction over the person, ( 3 ) improper venue, is not served!

Florida Panthers Men's, Cornell Water Filtration Plant, So An Entrance Shall Be Ministered, Demetric Felton Measurables, Seiko Prospex Srpd31j1, Dollar Shave Club Executive Handle Discontinued,